Nitto Trail Grappler M/T vs Toyo Open Country M/T
Here's a funny one: in LT285/70R17 these two mud tires are almost twins. Same load index, same 18.9/32" of tread, within a third of a pound of each other, and both come in sizes up to 26-inch wheels. They're even made by sister companies. The differences are price, road manners, and how long they last on pavement.
Updated November 12, 2026
Quick verdict
Buy the Nitto Trail Grappler if the truck drives to work Monday: Nitto tuned its tread to cut road noise, and it's $75 a tire cheaper at NTW in 285/70R17. Buy the Toyo Open Country M/T if you want the longest-wearing mud tire you can get and don't mind paying for it. Same size, same weight, same tread depth, no snowflake, no mileage warranty on either.

Nitto Trail Grappler M/T
Best for: Daily-driven mud trucks: quieter on the highway and cheaper
Strengths
- ✓Tread tuned to cancel its own noise, per Nitto
- ✓Three-ply sidewall on 17-inch and larger sizes
- ✓$75 less per tire than the Toyo in 285/70R17
Weaknesses
- ✗No mileage warranty
- ✗Fewer sizes than the Toyo
- ✗Wears faster than the Toyo on pavement

Toyo Open Country M/T
Best for: Mud tires that need to last through a lot of pavement
Strengths
- ✓Outlasts most mud tires on pavement
- ✓80 sizes up to 26-inch wheels
- ✓Same tread depth and weight as the Nitto
Weaknesses
- ✗Costs $75 more per tire in 285/70R17
- ✗No mileage warranty
- ✗Louder than the Trail Grappler on the highway
Spec Comparison
| Attribute | Nitto Trail Grappler M/T | Toyo Open Country M/T | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tire type | Mud-terrain | Mud-terrain | Tie |
| Severe snow rated (3PMSF) | No | No | Tie |
| Treadwear warranty | None stated | None (limited warranty only) | Tie |
| Tread depth, LT285/70R17 | 18.9/32" | 18.9/32" | Tie |
| Weight, LT285/70R17 (same load index) | 66.4 lb | 66.1 lb | Tie |
| Overall diameter, LT285/70R17 | 33.2" | 33.0" | Tie |
| Sizes available | 63 sizes, 15" to 26" wheels | 80 sizes, 15" to 26" wheels | Toyo Open Country M/T |
| Price at NTW, 285/70R17 (Nov 2026) | From $349 | From $424 | Nitto Trail Grappler M/T |
When to Choose Each
Commuting 40 miles a day on mud tires
Quieter and cheaper. You'll hear the difference before you see it.
Want the set to last as long as possible
The Toyo is the long-wearing mud tire. Pay up front, buy fewer sets.
Mud bogs and nothing else
Same tread depth, same weight, both built for it. Buy whichever fits the budget.
Odd size on a big lift
80 sizes against 63. Check the Toyo first.
Switching sizes when you upgrade? Check the fitment first — our free calculator compares diameter, ride-height, and speedometer error.
Tire Size Calculator →Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Nitto Trail Grappler better than the Toyo Open Country M/T?+
For a daily driver, yes: it's quieter on the highway and $75 a tire cheaper in 285/70R17. The Toyo wears longer and comes in more sizes. In LT285/70R17 they weigh the same and start with the same tread.
Are Nitto and Toyo the same company?+
They're sister brands under the same parent company. The tires are designed separately, which is why the Trail Grappler and the Open Country M/T feel different on the road even though they measure nearly the same.
Which is quieter, the Trail Grappler or the Toyo M/T?+
The Trail Grappler. Nitto designed its tread pattern to cancel road noise, which is why it's our F-150 mud pick for trucks that still commute. No mud tire is quiet, though.
Do either come with a mileage warranty?+
No. Neither the Trail Grappler nor the Toyo Open Country M/T carries a treadwear mileage warranty, which is normal for mud-terrain tires.
Related Pages
BFGoodrich KM3 vs Toyo Open Country M/T
The BFGoodrich KM3 is the mud tire for trucks that also crawl rock, and it's $83 less a tire in 285/70R17. The Toyo Open Country M/T outlasts most mud tires and comes in sizes up to 26-inch wheels.
CompareNitto Ridge Grappler vs Nitto Trail Grappler
Nitto’s hybrid versus its dedicated mud-terrain: the street-friendly Ridge Grappler against the aggressive Trail Grappler M/T.
BestBest Mud Tires for Ford F-150
The best mud tire for a Ford F-150 is the BFGoodrich KM3 if you also see rocks, the Toyo Open Country M/T if you want it to last, and the Nitto Trail Grappler if you have to drive it to work on Monday.
Check both in your size
NTW stocks the Trail Grappler and the Open Country M/T. See every size and the current price.
Rather order off Amazon? Nitto Trail Grappler M/T · Toyo Open Country M/T